{ "schemaVersion": "1.2", "type": "tutorial-evidence-record", "language": "zh-CN", "generatedAt": "2026-10-01", "publisher": { "id": "https://zenleak.cn/#organization", "name": "ZenLeak GEO 学院", "editorialName": "ZenLeak 编辑部", "contact": "geo@allintwo.cloud" }, "policies": { "sourceRelationship": "Page sources provide general context. Explicit claim evidence includes a source excerpt, locator, relation, review date and limits; unmapped claims do not imply one-to-one source support.", "rankingDisclaimer": "Inclusion in this evidence layer does not guarantee search ranking, indexing, citation, recommendation, or adoption by an AI system." }, "record": { "id": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "title": "AI 搜索出现来源，是否等于引用了你的网页？从品牌提及到页面引用的核验方法", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/", "path": "/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/", "evidenceUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "representations": { "json": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation.json", "markdown": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation.md" }, "category": "实验室", "contentType": "experiment", "status": "reviewed", "statusLabel": "已复核", "datePublished": "2026-10-01", "dateModified": "2026-10-01", "reviewedAt": "2026-10-01", "evidenceReviewedAt": "2026-10-01", "claims": [ { "id": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-1", "text": "AI 回答出现品牌名称、来源卡片或本站 URL，分别对应品牌提及、来源出现和页面引用；任何一项成立，都不能自动推出内容被采用、引用准确或回答完整。", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-1", "articleUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-1", "evidence": [ { "tutorialId": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "claimText": "AI 回答出现品牌名称、来源卡片或本站 URL，分别对应品牌提及、来源出现和页面引用；任何一项成立，都不能自动推出内容被采用、引用准确或回答完整。", "relation": "inference", "sourceUrl": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09848", "sourceTitle": "Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines", "locator": "Abstract：citation recall 与 citation precision", "excerpt": "systems should cite comprehensively (high citation recall; all statements are fully supported by citations) and accurately (high citation precision; every cite supports its associated statement).", "checkedAt": "2026-10-01", "limits": "论文支持区分引用完整性与引用准确性；品牌提及、来源出现、页面链接和内容采用是 ZenLeak 为平台观察增加的记录维度，不是论文定义的全部状态。" } ] }, { "id": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-2", "text": "核验页面引用应把回答拆成最小可核查声明，逐条关联来源位置、目标页面版本和支持理由，检查主体、范围、条件、时间与结论强度是否一致。", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-2", "articleUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-2", "evidence": [ { "tutorialId": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "claimText": "核验页面引用应把回答拆成最小可核查声明，逐条关联来源位置、目标页面版本和支持理由，检查主体、范围、条件、时间与结论强度是否一致。", "relation": "context", "sourceUrl": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-overview/", "sourceTitle": "W3C PROV-Overview", "locator": "Provenance information and its use for assessing quality and reliability", "excerpt": "Provenance is information about entities, activities, and people involved in producing a piece of data or thing, which can be used to assess its quality, reliability or trustworthiness.", "checkedAt": "2026-10-01", "limits": "W3C 提供来源关系的通用模型；声明拆解、来源位置、页面版本和审核理由是 ZenLeak 面向 AI 引用观察的操作设计，不是 W3C 规定的审核表。" } ] }, { "id": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-3", "text": "可复测的 AI 引用研究需要冻结平台、问题、语言、地区、登录状态、联网模式、页面版本和观察窗口；未知、未执行、拒答和来源不明应单独保留。", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-3", "articleUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-3", "evidence": [ { "tutorialId": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "claimText": "可复测的 AI 引用研究需要冻结平台、问题、语言、地区、登录状态、联网模式、页面版本和观察窗口；未知、未执行、拒答和来源不明应单独保留。", "relation": "first-party", "sourceUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/benchmarks/", "sourceTitle": "ZenLeak 国内 AI 引用基准库", "locator": "固定问题集、观察窗口、平台字段与 null 值规则", "excerpt": "基准库使用固定中文问题和多个国内 AI 平台，分别记录联网、来源、品牌提及、页面引用、内容采用、引用准确和回答完整，并保留观察窗口与限制。", "checkedAt": "2026-10-01", "limits": "这是 ZenLeak 的第一方实验设计，不是任何 AI 平台的官方测试规范，也不能保证在固定条件下得到稳定回答。" } ] }, { "id": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-4", "text": "统计结果必须同时公开计划数、已记录数、完整回答数、可判定数和各维度分母；一次回答出现本站来源不能推出平台长期引用、搜索收录或流量增长。", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/evidence/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-4", "articleUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation/#ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation-claim-4", "evidence": [ { "tutorialId": "ai-citation-mention-vs-page-citation", "claimText": "统计结果必须同时公开计划数、已记录数、完整回答数、可判定数和各维度分母；一次回答出现本站来源不能推出平台长期引用、搜索收录或流量增长。", "relation": "first-party", "sourceUrl": "https://zenleak.cn/benchmarks.json", "sourceTitle": "ZenLeak 国内 AI 引用基准 JSON", "locator": "summary、platformSummaries 与 interpretationPolicy 字段", "excerpt": "基准 JSON 将 records 与 protocolRecords 分开，并明确 nullIsUnknown、brandMentionIsNotPageCitation、pageCitationIsNotAccurateCitation 和 manualObservationIsNotPlatformOfficialData。", "checkedAt": "2026-10-01", "limits": "机器可读基准只反映公开记录与协议口径；它不提供平台长期规律、搜索收录或流量因果证明。" } ] } ], "sources": [ { "label": "ZenLeak 国内 AI 引用基准库", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/benchmarks/", "publisher": "ZenLeak 实验室" }, { "label": "ZenLeak AI 搜索引用证据归档方法", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-evidence-record/", "publisher": "ZenLeak 实验室" }, { "label": "Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines", "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2304.09848", "publisher": "arXiv" }, { "label": "Enabling Large Language Models to Generate Text with Citations", "url": "https://aclanthology.org/2023.emnlp-main.398/", "publisher": "ACL Anthology" }, { "label": "PROV-Overview", "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-overview/", "publisher": "W3C" }, { "label": "Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content", "url": "https://developers.google.com/search/docs/fundamentals/creating-helpful-content", "publisher": "Google Search Central" } ], "prerequisites": [ { "id": "domestic-ai-citation-benchmark-method", "title": "国内 AI 引用实验怎么做：从固定问题到可复核结果", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/experiments/domestic-ai-citation-benchmark-method/" }, { "id": "ai-citation-evidence-record", "title": "AI 搜索引用证据怎么归档：从原始回答到可复核记录", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-evidence-record/" }, { "id": "ai-citation-accuracy", "title": "AI 引用了你的网站，就算 GEO 成功吗？引用准确性的核查方法", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/experiments/ai-citation-accuracy/" } ], "related": [ { "id": "domestic-ai-citation-benchmark-method", "title": "国内 AI 引用实验怎么做：从固定问题到可复核结果", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/experiments/domestic-ai-citation-benchmark-method/" }, { "id": "ai-citation-evidence-record", "title": "AI 搜索引用证据怎么归档：从原始回答到可复核记录", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/ai-citation-evidence-record/" }, { "id": "ai-citation-accuracy", "title": "AI 引用了你的网站，就算 GEO 成功吗？引用准确性的核查方法", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/experiments/ai-citation-accuracy/" }, { "id": "ai-search-result-variation", "title": "AI 搜索结果为什么每次不一样：GEO 实验中的环境冻结与重复验证方法", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/experiments/ai-search-result-variation/" }, { "id": "geo-discovery-vs-citation", "title": "GEO 实验如何区分被发现、被收录与被 AI 引用：ZenLeak Day 3 复测记录", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/geo-discovery-vs-citation/" }, { "id": "evidence-and-sources", "title": "GEO 证据怎么组织：来源、引用与可信度", "url": "https://zenleak.cn/content/evidence-and-sources/" } ] } }